What’s the best way to sell crafted tonics for profit?

Selling crafted tonics for profit in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a reliable way to earn money, especially if you focus on high-value recipes and efficient gathering methods. Tonics are consumable items that restore health, stamina, or Dead Eye, and they can be crafted using herbs and other ingredients found throughout the game world. To maximize profit, you need to focus on crafting tonics that sell for higher prices and gather ingredients in bulk.\n\nFirst, you’ll need to unlock the necessary recipes. Many tonic recipes are available by default, but others can be purchased from Fences or found in the world. For example, the Potent Health Cure recipe, which sells for a high price, can be bought from the Fence in Rhodes. Focus on crafting Potent Health Cures, Potent Snake Oils, and Potent Miracle Tonics, as these are among the most valuable tonics in the game.\n\nNext, gather the required ingredients. Herbs like Yarrow, Ginseng, and Sage are essential for crafting tonics. These can be found in specific regions: Yarrow is common in the Heartlands, Ginseng grows in forests like Roanoke Ridge, and Sage is abundant in the plains of West Elizabeth. Use Eagle Eye to highlight herbs and make gathering easier. Additionally, collect animal fat from ducks, geese, and boars, as it’s a key ingredient for Potent Health Cures.\n\nOnce you have the ingredients, craft the tonics at a campfire. Open the crafting menu, select the tonic you want to make, and confirm the recipe. Crafting in bulk is more efficient, so gather as many ingredients as possible before starting. Keep in mind that some tonics require specific herbs or items, so plan your gathering routes accordingly.\n\nTo sell your tonics, visit a Doctor or General Store. Doctors typically offer better prices for tonics, so prioritize selling to them. For example, the Doctor in Valentine or Saint Denis is a good option. Open the sell menu, select the tonics, and confirm the transaction. Selling in bulk can net you a significant amount of money, especially if you’ve crafted high-value tonics like Potent Health Cures.\n\nOne common challenge is running out of ingredients. To avoid this, plan your gathering trips carefully. Use the in-game map to mark herb locations and revisit them regularly, as herbs respawn over time. Additionally, consider hunting animals for fat and other ingredients while gathering herbs to maximize efficiency.\n\nFor new players, focus on unlocking recipes and gathering herbs in safe areas like the Heartlands. Experienced players can optimize their routes by combining herb gathering with other activities, such as hunting or treasure hunting. Always carry a Varmint Rifle for hunting ducks and geese, as they provide animal fat and feathers, which can also be sold for profit.\n\nIn summary, selling crafted tonics for profit requires a combination of recipe knowledge, efficient gathering, and strategic selling. Focus on high-value tonics, gather ingredients in bulk, and sell to Doctors for the best prices. With practice, you can turn tonic crafting into a steady source of income in Red Dead Redemption 2.