What causes the "Arthur not gaining weight" issue, and how do I fix it?

The ''Arthur not gaining weight'' issue in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a common problem that players encounter when trying to manage Arthur Morgan''s weight. Weight in RDR2 is tied to Arthur''s health, stamina, and overall appearance, and it fluctuates based on his diet, activity level, and rest. If Arthur is not gaining weight despite eating regularly, it could be due to several factors, including overexertion, insufficient calorie intake, or a bug in the game''s mechanics.\n\nFirst, it''s important to understand how weight works in RDR2. Arthur''s weight is categorized into three states: underweight, average, and overweight. Each state affects his core stats differently. For example, being underweight reduces his health core but increases his stamina regeneration, while being overweight does the opposite. To gain weight, Arthur needs to consume more calories than he burns. This means eating high-calorie foods like cooked meats, canned goods, and candies regularly.\n\nOne common reason Arthur may not gain weight is that he is burning too many calories through physical activity. Activities like running, swimming, or fighting consume energy, which can offset the calories gained from eating. To fix this, reduce Arthur''s physical exertion and focus on resting more often. For example, instead of running everywhere, use your horse to travel. Additionally, avoid long periods of sprinting or engaging in combat unnecessarily.\n\nAnother factor is the type of food Arthur consumes. Not all foods provide the same amount of calories. For example, a single piece of cooked meat provides more calories than a handful of berries. To maximize weight gain, prioritize high-calorie foods like big game meat, which can be obtained by hunting large animals such as bears or alligators. Cook this meat at a campfire to increase its calorie content further. You can also purchase canned goods like baked beans or salted offal from general stores in towns like Valentine or Saint Denis.\n\nIf Arthur is still not gaining weight despite eating high-calorie foods and reducing physical activity, it could be a bug. Some players have reported that the weight system can glitch, especially after long play sessions or during specific missions. To address this, try saving your game and restarting the console or PC. This often resets the game''s mechanics and can resolve the issue. Additionally, avoid using mods or cheats, as these can interfere with the weight system.\n\nFinally, monitor Arthur''s weight regularly by checking his stats in the player menu. This will help you track progress and adjust your strategy as needed. If you''re still struggling, consider using the ''Big Game Meat + Thyme'' recipe, which provides a significant health boost and high calorie count. Hunt in areas like Big Valley or Roanoke Ridge for reliable sources of big game meat.\n\nIn summary, to fix the ''Arthur not gaining weight'' issue, focus on consuming high-calorie foods, reducing physical activity, and ensuring the game is running smoothly. By following these steps, you can effectively manage Arthur''s weight and optimize his performance in the game.