What happens if Arthur doesn’t help Tilly in the final missions?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan’s choices significantly impact the game’s ending. One of the critical moments in the story involves Tilly Jackson, a member of the Van der Linde gang. If Arthur chooses not to help Tilly during her mission, it affects the narrative and Arthur’s honor, but it does not drastically alter the main story’s outcome. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what happens and how it impacts gameplay.\n\nTilly’s mission, titled ‘The Fine Art of Conversation,’ occurs in Chapter 4. During this mission, Tilly is confronted by members of the Foreman Brothers, a rival gang. Arthur has the option to intervene and help her. If you choose not to help Tilly, the mission will fail, and Arthur’s honor will decrease. This decision reflects poorly on Arthur’s character, as it shows a lack of loyalty to his gang members. However, the story will continue regardless of this choice, as Tilly’s fate is not tied to the main storyline’s conclusion.\n\nFrom a gameplay perspective, failing to help Tilly means missing out on a significant honor boost. Helping her increases Arthur’s honor, which is crucial for unlocking the high-honor ending. High honor leads to a more positive conclusion for Arthur, while low honor results in a darker, more tragic ending. If you’re aiming for the high-honor ending, it’s essential to assist Tilly and other gang members whenever possible.\n\nTo complete Tilly’s mission successfully, you must follow her to the location where she is confronted by the Foreman Brothers. This occurs near the Rhodes train station. Once the confrontation begins, you’ll need to engage in combat with the Foreman Brothers. Use cover effectively and aim for headshots to quickly eliminate enemies. After the fight, Tilly will thank Arthur, and the mission will conclude with an honor increase.\n\nIf you choose not to help Tilly, the mission will end abruptly, and Arthur will lose honor. This decision can make it harder to achieve the high-honor ending later in the game. To mitigate this, you can perform other honorable actions, such as helping strangers in need, donating to camp, or sparing enemies during random encounters. These actions will help balance out the honor loss from failing Tilly’s mission.\n\nIn summary, while not helping Tilly doesn’t change the main story’s outcome, it does affect Arthur’s honor and the player’s ability to achieve the high-honor ending. To maximize your chances of a positive conclusion, always prioritize helping gang members and making honorable choices throughout the game. This approach ensures a more fulfilling narrative experience and aligns with Arthur’s character development.\n\nPractical tips for players: Always save your game before critical missions to explore different outcomes. If you’re aiming for high honor, focus on helping gang members and strangers. Use the game’s honor system as a guide for making decisions, and remember that small actions can have a significant impact on the story’s conclusion.