What happens if Arthur doesn’t help Mary-Beth in the final missions?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan’s interactions with Mary-Beth, a member of the Van der Linde gang, play a significant role in shaping his character arc and the game’s narrative. However, if Arthur chooses not to help Mary-Beth during the final missions, it can impact the story and Arthur’s moral alignment. Mary-Beth’s missions are optional, but they contribute to Arthur’s redemption journey, which is central to the game’s themes.\n\nMary-Beth’s final mission, titled ‘The Fine Art of Conversation,’ occurs in Chapter 6. During this mission, Arthur meets Mary-Beth at the Valentine train station, where she expresses her concerns about the gang’s future and her desire to leave. If Arthur chooses not to help her, the mission will not progress, and Mary-Beth will remain in the gang camp. This decision does not drastically alter the main storyline, but it does affect Arthur’s honor level and the emotional weight of his journey.\n\nFrom a gameplay perspective, skipping Mary-Beth’s mission means missing out on a key moment of reflection for Arthur. The mission provides insight into his relationships with other gang members and his growing disillusionment with Dutch’s leadership. By not engaging with Mary-Beth, players lose the opportunity to deepen Arthur’s character development and witness his internal struggle between loyalty and morality.\n\nTo complete Mary-Beth’s mission, players must first ensure they are in Chapter 6 and have progressed far enough in the main story. The mission marker will appear at the Valentine train station, and Arthur must approach Mary-Beth to initiate the conversation. During the mission, Arthur will escort her to a nearby location, where they discuss the gang’s future and Arthur’s personal regrets. This interaction is crucial for players aiming for a high honor ending, as it reinforces Arthur’s path toward redemption.\n\nIf players choose not to help Mary-Beth, they should be aware of the consequences. Arthur’s honor level may decrease slightly, and the emotional impact of the story may feel less profound. Additionally, skipping this mission means missing out on unique dialogue and character moments that enrich the narrative. For players aiming to experience the full depth of Arthur’s story, completing Mary-Beth’s mission is highly recommended.\n\nFor those who want to maximize their honor and fully explore Arthur’s redemption arc, engaging with Mary-Beth and other optional missions is essential. These missions often provide opportunities to make morally positive choices, such as helping others or reflecting on past actions. By participating in these moments, players can ensure Arthur’s story resonates more deeply and aligns with the game’s themes of redemption and sacrifice.\n\nIn summary, while skipping Mary-Beth’s mission does not drastically change the main storyline, it does affect Arthur’s character development and honor level. Players should consider the emotional and narrative impact of their choices, especially if they aim for a high honor ending. Completing optional missions like Mary-Beth’s is a key part of experiencing the full depth of Red Dead Redemption 2’s story.