What are the consequences of Arthur’s choices in Saint Denis?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, Arthur Morgan''s choices in Saint Denis significantly impact the game''s narrative and endings. These choices are tied to the game''s honor system, which influences Arthur''s moral alignment and the ultimate outcome of the story. The key moment in Saint Denis occurs during Chapter 4, where Arthur must make critical decisions during missions like ''Brothers and Sisters, One and All'' and ''The Gilded Cage.'' These missions test Arthur''s loyalty to the gang and his personal values, shaping his path toward redemption or downfall.\n\nDuring ''Brothers and Sisters, One and All,'' Arthur encounters a group of labor union protesters. Players can choose to intervene violently or peacefully. If Arthur uses force, his honor decreases, reinforcing his role as an outlaw. Conversely, resolving the situation peacefully increases his honor, reflecting his desire for redemption. This choice is pivotal because it sets the tone for Arthur''s character development and influences how other characters perceive him later in the story.\n\nIn ''The Gilded Cage,'' Arthur interacts with high society figures, including Angelo Bronte, a powerful crime boss. Players must decide whether to follow Dutch''s aggressive plans or take a more cautious approach. For example, during the mission, Arthur can choose to intimidate or negotiate with Bronte. Aggressive actions lower honor, while diplomatic choices raise it. These decisions not only affect Arthur''s honor but also impact the gang''s dynamics, as Dutch''s trust in Arthur may waver if he deviates from the plan.\n\nAnother critical moment in Saint Denis is Arthur''s encounter with Sister Calderón during the mission ''A Fine Night of Debauchery.'' If Arthur has high honor, he can have a heartfelt conversation with her about his regrets and aspirations. This interaction is a turning point for Arthur''s redemption arc, as it reinforces his desire to change and help others. However, if Arthur has low honor, this opportunity is lost, and his path remains tied to his outlaw lifestyle.\n\nThe consequences of these choices extend beyond Saint Denis. Arthur''s honor level determines which of the four possible endings he receives. High honor leads to a more peaceful and redemptive conclusion, while low honor results in a tragic and violent end. For example, in the high honor ending, Arthur helps John Marston escape and secures his family''s future, symbolizing his redemption. In contrast, the low honor ending sees Arthur succumb to his darker impulses, leaving a legacy of chaos.\n\nTo maximize your chances of achieving the high honor ending, focus on making morally upright decisions throughout the game. Help strangers in need, donate to the camp, and avoid unnecessary violence. In Saint Denis, prioritize peaceful resolutions during missions and side activities. For instance, during ''Brothers and Sisters, One and All,'' avoid attacking the protesters and instead de-escalate the situation. Similarly, in ''The Gilded Cage,'' choose dialogue options that emphasize restraint and diplomacy.\n\nPractical tips for managing Arthur''s honor include regularly checking the honor bar in the player menu and engaging in activities that boost honor, such as fishing, hunting, and assisting NPCs. Additionally, avoid antagonizing civilians or committing crimes in Saint Denis, as the city''s high population density makes it easy to lose honor quickly. By carefully navigating Arthur''s choices in Saint Denis and beyond, players can shape his legacy and unlock the ending that aligns with their vision for his story.\n\nIn summary, Arthur''s choices in Saint Denis are crucial to his character arc and the game''s multiple endings. By prioritizing high honor decisions and focusing on redemption, players can guide Arthur toward a more fulfilling conclusion. Pay attention to the moral implications of each choice, and remember that even small actions can have a significant impact on Arthur''s journey.