What’s the most profitable way to sell herbs to the general store?

Selling herbs in Red Dead Redemption 2 can be a steady source of income, but maximizing your profits requires understanding the game mechanics and optimizing your approach. Herbs are abundant in the game world, and while they may not fetch high prices individually, selling them in bulk or crafting them into more valuable items can significantly increase your earnings. Here’s a detailed guide to making the most profit from selling herbs to the general store.\n\nFirst, it’s important to know where to find herbs. Herbs like Yarrow, Wild Carrot, and Ginseng are scattered across the map, but some locations are more herb-dense than others. For example, the Heartlands region near Valentine is rich in Yarrow, while the forests around Roanoke Ridge are great for finding Ginseng. Use your Eagle Eye ability (L3 + R3 on PlayStation or LS + RS on Xbox) to highlight herbs in the environment, making them easier to spot. Focus on areas with diverse vegetation, as these tend to have a higher concentration of herbs.\n\nOnce you’ve gathered a variety of herbs, the next step is deciding how to sell them. Selling herbs directly to the general store is straightforward but not always the most profitable. For example, a single Yarrow plant sells for around $0.25, while Ginseng sells for $0.50. However, crafting these herbs into tonics or other consumables can increase their value. For instance, crafting a Potent Health Cure using Yarrow and a Ginseng Elixir using Ginseng can double or even triple their worth. Crafting requires a campfire or access to a crafting menu, so plan accordingly.\n\nTo maximize profits, focus on high-value herbs like Ginseng, Sage, and Burdock Root. These herbs are rarer but sell for more. Additionally, some herbs are used in specific challenges or missions, so holding onto them until you unlock these opportunities can yield better rewards. For example, completing the Herbalist Challenges requires collecting specific herbs, and selling them afterward can be more lucrative.\n\nAnother tip is to sell herbs in bulk. General stores and other vendors have limited funds, so selling large quantities at once can deplete their cash reserves. To avoid this, visit multiple stores or wait for their funds to replenish. Alternatively, you can sell herbs to the Trapper, who often pays more for certain items. However, the Trapper is not always accessible, so general stores remain the most reliable option.\n\nOne common challenge is managing inventory space. Herbs can quickly fill up your satchel, so prioritize high-value herbs and discard or use low-value ones. You can also upgrade your satchel at Pearson’s crafting station in camp to carry more items. The Legend of the East Satchel, for example, allows you to carry 99 of each herb, making it easier to stockpile and sell in bulk.\n\nFinally, consider the time investment. While herb gathering can be profitable, it’s not the fastest way to make money in Red Dead Redemption 2. If you’re short on time, focus on other activities like hunting or treasure hunting, which offer higher payouts. However, for players who enjoy exploring and gathering, selling herbs can be a relaxing and rewarding way to earn money.\n\nIn summary, the most profitable way to sell herbs involves gathering high-value herbs, crafting them into more valuable items, and selling them in bulk. Use Eagle Eye to locate herbs efficiently, upgrade your satchel to carry more, and consider selling to the Trapper for better prices. While herb selling may not be the fastest money-making method, it’s a reliable and enjoyable way to supplement your income in the game.