What are the consequences of siding with Dutch or Micah?

In Red Dead Redemption 2, the choice to side with Dutch or Micah during the final missions significantly impacts the game''s ending and Arthur Morgan''s legacy. This decision occurs in Chapter 6, during the mission ''Red Dead Redemption,'' where Arthur must confront Micah and Dutch at Beaver Hollow. The consequences of your choice are tied to Arthur''s honor level, which influences the ending you receive. High honor leads to a more peaceful resolution, while low honor results in a darker outcome.\n\nIf you choose to side with Dutch, Arthur will attempt to reason with him, urging him to abandon Micah and his destructive path. This choice reflects Arthur''s loyalty to the gang''s original ideals and his hope for redemption. However, Dutch remains indecisive and ultimately sides with Micah, leading to a tense confrontation. The outcome of this choice depends on your honor level. With high honor, Arthur secures John Marston''s escape, ensuring his survival and setting up the events of the first Red Dead Redemption game. With low honor, Arthur''s efforts are less successful, and the ending feels more tragic.\n\nOn the other hand, siding with Micah aligns Arthur with the gang''s darker tendencies. This choice is often seen as a betrayal of Arthur''s moral growth, especially if you''ve been playing with high honor. Micah represents greed and chaos, and siding with him leads to a more violent and morally ambiguous ending. High honor still allows Arthur to help John escape, but the tone is more somber. Low honor results in a grim conclusion, with Arthur succumbing to his illness and Micah''s influence.\n\nTo unlock the best possible ending, prioritize building Arthur''s honor throughout the game. Engage in positive actions like helping strangers, donating to camp funds, and making morally upright decisions during missions. For example, sparing lives during robberies or choosing to help the Downes family early in the game will boost your honor. Conversely, committing crimes, antagonizing NPCs, or making selfish choices will lower it. Your honor level is displayed in the player menu, so monitor it regularly.\n\nDuring the final missions, your choices in dialogue and actions will reflect your honor. For instance, in ''Red Dead Redemption,'' high honor prompts Arthur to prioritize John''s safety over personal revenge. Low honor, however, leads Arthur to focus on settling scores, even at the cost of others'' well-being. The game''s mechanics ensure that your decisions feel impactful, with cutscenes and dialogue adapting to your honor level.\n\nPractical tips for achieving the desired ending include completing side missions that reward honor, such as helping the veteran in ''The Veteran'' stranger mission or assisting the widow Charlotte in ''The Widow of Willard''s Rest.'' Additionally, avoid unnecessary violence and theft, as these actions can quickly lower your honor. If you''re struggling to maintain high honor, consider replaying earlier chapters to make better choices.\n\nUltimately, the consequences of siding with Dutch or Micah are deeply tied to Arthur''s journey and the player''s choices. By focusing on honor and making thoughtful decisions, you can shape Arthur''s legacy and unlock the ending that best reflects your playstyle. Whether you seek redemption or embrace chaos, the game''s narrative ensures a memorable conclusion to Arthur''s story.