How do I complete "The Sheep and the Goats" without killing anyone?

Completing ''The Sheep and the Goats'' mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 without killing anyone requires careful planning, stealth, and understanding of the game mechanics. This mission is part of Chapter 2 and involves stealing sheep from a ranch owned by the Grays, a rival family. The key to a non-lethal approach is avoiding direct confrontation and using stealth to complete objectives.\n\nFirst, ensure you have the right tools for stealth. Equip yourself with a bow or throwing knives, as these are silent weapons. Avoid using firearms, as they will alert enemies and escalate the situation. Additionally, wear clothing that blends into the environment, such as dark or neutral tones, to reduce visibility. Before starting the mission, stock up on health tonics and horse stimulants to ensure you can escape quickly if detected.\n\nWhen the mission begins, follow John Marston to the ranch. Once you arrive, you will need to herd the sheep into a pen. This part is straightforward and does not involve combat. However, after herding the sheep, you will be confronted by ranch hands. This is where stealth becomes crucial. Instead of engaging in a shootout, use the environment to your advantage. Stay crouched to remain undetected and move slowly to avoid drawing attention.\n\nIf you are spotted, do not panic. Use the ''Deadeye'' mechanic to mark and disarm enemies without killing them. Aim for their weapons or legs to incapacitate them temporarily. Alternatively, use non-lethal takedowns by sneaking up behind enemies and pressing the appropriate button prompt. This will knock them out without causing fatal harm.\n\nAfter dealing with the ranch hands, focus on escaping with the sheep. Mount your horse and herd the sheep toward the designated area. Keep an eye on the minimap for enemy positions and avoid direct paths if possible. If you encounter more enemies, use the same stealth tactics to evade or incapacitate them. Remember, the goal is to avoid killing anyone, so prioritize evasion over confrontation.\n\nOne common challenge is managing the sheep during the escape. Sheep can be slow and unpredictable, so use your horse to guide them effectively. Stay close to the sheep to keep them moving in the right direction, but avoid pushing them too hard, as they may scatter. If you lose control of the sheep, quickly regroup and continue herding them toward the objective.\n\nFinally, once you reach the drop-off point, the mission will conclude. By following these steps, you can complete ''The Sheep and the Goats'' without killing anyone, earning the satisfaction of a clean, non-lethal approach. This method also aligns with Arthur Morgan''s moral code if you are playing a high-honor playthrough.\n\nIn summary, completing ''The Sheep and the Goats'' without killing anyone requires stealth, patience, and careful use of game mechanics. Equip silent weapons, use stealth to avoid detection, and prioritize non-lethal takedowns when necessary. Herd the sheep efficiently and escape without engaging in unnecessary combat. With these strategies, you can successfully complete the mission while maintaining your honor and avoiding bloodshed.