What is the best way to catch fish without scaring them in RDR2?

Fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a relaxing and rewarding activity, but it can be frustrating if you scare the fish away. To catch fish effectively without scaring them, you need to understand the game mechanics and follow specific steps. First, ensure you have the right equipment. You’ll need a fishing rod, which can be obtained during the mission ''A Fisher of Men'' in Chapter 2. You’ll also need bait or lures, which can be purchased from general stores or crafted using specific materials.\n\nWhen approaching a fishing spot, move slowly and avoid making sudden movements. Fish are sensitive to noise and vibrations, so running or jumping near the water will scare them away. Crouch or walk slowly to the edge of the water to minimize disturbances. Once you’re in position, equip your fishing rod and select the appropriate bait or lure for the type of fish you’re targeting. Different fish species prefer different bait, so check your compendium or use special lures like the Lake Lure, River Lure, or Swamp Lure for better results.\n\nCast your line by holding the aim button and releasing it when the marker is in the desired spot. Avoid casting too close to the fish, as this can startle them. Instead, aim slightly ahead of their swimming path. Once your line is in the water, wait patiently for a bite. Fish are more likely to bite if you use the correct bait and cast in areas where they are visibly swimming. Look for ripples or splashes in the water to identify active fish.\n\nWhen a fish bites, quickly press the hook button to set the hook. Then, use the reeling mechanic to bring the fish in. Be careful not to reel too quickly, as this can break the line. Instead, alternate between reeling and pulling the rod upward to tire the fish out. If the fish struggles, stop reeling and let it swim for a moment before resuming. This back-and-forth motion is key to successfully landing the fish without losing it.\n\nSome of the best fishing spots in RDR2 include O’Creagh’s Run for Lake Sturgeon, the Dakota River near Valentine for Smallmouth Bass, and the Kamassa River for Channel Catfish. These locations are known for their high fish populations and are ideal for practicing your technique. Additionally, fishing during specific times of day, such as early morning or late afternoon, can increase your chances of success, as fish are more active during these periods.\n\nTo avoid common challenges, always check your line durability and carry extra bait or lures. If you’re struggling to catch a specific fish, try switching to a different type of bait or lure. For example, if you’re targeting Legendary Fish, use the Special Lure available from the bait shop in Lagras. Lastly, be mindful of your surroundings. Predators or hostile NPCs can interrupt your fishing, so always keep an eye out for potential threats.\n\nIn summary, catching fish without scaring them in RDR2 requires patience, the right equipment, and a good understanding of the game’s mechanics. Move slowly, use the correct bait, and cast your line strategically. Practice your reeling technique and choose the best fishing spots to maximize your success. With these tips, you’ll be reeling in fish like a pro in no time.